Skip to main content
Search

The Fed’s dilemma

Date: 12 September 2025

4 minute read

Lady using a laptop

This week’s blog is written by portfolio manager Sacha Chorley

Investor confidence in a September rate cut is high, with US equities at record levels and bond markets reflecting dovish expectations. The Federal Reserve faces a complex set of signals and this week we focus on some of the data likely to drive the decision.

The next interest rate decision will be taken by the Federal Reserve in its meeting on 17 September. The equity market in the US is now trading at its all-time high, with bond market expectations set for an interest rate cut of 25 basis points. Ahead of this, it’s worth exploring some of the data that may contribute to the Fed’s decision and what this might mean for markets.

Labour market cooling from a strong base

We can start by considering how strong the labour market is. The widely followed non-farm payroll (NFP) number showed that only 22,000 employees were added to US-wide payrolls over August. To put this into context, through the period between 2010 and pre-Covid, the average monthly NFP data point was closer to +175k employees, while payroll growth turns negative as the economy enters recession territory.

Payrolls are just one lens through which to view the employment market, but similar levels of deceleration are also visible through other data points. For example, through 2023 we observed that the US labour market was such that the number of job openings far exceeded the number of unemployed people, with this void suggesting robust underlying economic activity. By July of this year, the picture had flipped: there were now fewer job vacancies than unemployed, suggesting that the economy was seeing weaker demand.

That being said, it’s worth noting that while these data points suggest a negative change, this is from a solid base - and this is true again when considering the job market in a number of ways. For example, the unemployment rate at 4.3% is close to cyclical lows, while numbers of people initiating or continuing jobless benefit claims are below what has been experienced in prior cycle lows.

Mixed signals from inflation and corporate performance

Outside of employment statistics, we continue to see that corporate performance, both in the public markets and as reflected in economy-wide statistics, show that businesses continue to grow their profits. There is certainly optimism in public equity markets, where forecasts suggest earnings growth over the next two years will be well over 20% cumulatively, although we would caution that this is likely due to a bias towards faster-growing technology companies present in public markets. Hard economic data points covering the whole economy (such as industrial production growth rates) suggest a level of growth that is positive although uninspiring, and this is corroborated in surveys of business activity, where some participants have reflected concern about impending tariff impacts.

Indeed, from an inflationary perspective, the tariffs are feeding through into prices: the August data points for Consumer Price Index (CPI) have seen grocery prices rising as a direct result of tariffs, for example, on fruit and vegetable imports from Mexico. These effects might well build over the next few months and this could drag inflation rates higher. One might expect the tariff impacts to be a one-time phenomenon and therefore something the Fed can look through – however, second-round effects whereby workers demand higher wages to offset their higher cost-of-living could then prompt further rises in inflation.

When taken together, this data would suggest that a rate cut would be justified – mainly because of the weakening trend of the employment market. Equally, there are no strong or obvious signs that the US economy is about to immediately tip into a deep recession.

Crucially, we are not in the business of forecasting economic growth or trying to position the portfolios based on our guesses of what the Fed will do. At this juncture it is striking that both the bond and equity markets appear sanguine, at least in part due to reasonably full expectations of the Fed’s cutting cycle. Again, this is not to say that these expectations are unreasonable, but rather to highlight that when the market is so one way, disappointment, should it occur, is likely to result in larger levels of volatility.

Portfolio manager blog - this week written by

Sacha Chorley

Portfolio Manager

Sacha is a portfolio manager of the Quilter Investors Cirilium and Creation Portfolios. Prior to joining Quilter Investors in 2011, Sacha worked at Broadstone with their team of economists before moving into asset allocation and fund manager research.

Sacha is a CFA charterholder and has also completed the Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst qualification. Sacha has a degree in Maths from the University of Bath.

Last week's portfolio manager blog

What’s driving the gilt sell-off?

As gilt yields climbed sharply through August, CJ Cowan explores the factors behind the sell-off, from shifting inflation expectations to concerns over the UK’s fiscal outlook.

Read the previous blog